Welcome to Anthony's Pizzeria Warren

“ Upon relocating to Warren, I genuinely sought a pizza joint that felt authentically local — not a franchise, not hurried, merely a community spot where individuals truly care about what they provide.Anthony’s Pizzeria is precisely that type of place, and I’m truly happy that I discovered it.Right from the initial phone call, I sensed that this place was unique.The man who picked up the call was very amiable, tolerant, and approachable.He even offered me a discount on the pizza, which was surprising but greatly appreciated.Upon my arrival, it was evident that he was managing the shop on his own, aided only by his delivery drivers.It's evident when someone has pride in their business, and that was clear as soon as I entered.He showed me kindness and respect throughout, engaged in conversation, and truly made me feel at home — as if I were already a regular.Such service is uncommon nowadays, particularly in dining establishments, and it truly distinguished itself above all else.It seemed more like backing a local guy passionate about his work than just grabbing food.Now let's discuss the pizza, as it certainly met our expectations.I requested additional cheese, and believe me — he came through.This pizza was packed in the most enjoyable manner.Not merely dusted with cheese, but genuinely cheesy.Cozy, new, and prepared perfectly.I arrived about 15 minutes late to collect it and was certain it would be lukewarm by the time I reached home, particularly with the chilly winter conditions.No.It remained warm, still new, and still incredible when I opened the box.The taste, the consistency, and the standard were all spot on.This is clearly a person who values doing it properly and avoiding shortcuts.Anthony’s Pizzeria is precisely the type of neighborhood place Warren requires.Delicious food, excellent service, and even more amazing individuals.I’m glad to have them in the city and will definitely return.Strongly suggested for anyone seeking an authentic neighborhood pizza place executed well. ”

“ Carry out only, their pizza was okay, a little underdone I think it could have probably cooked for another 2 minutes or so to get a little crispier, but he uses a sweet sauce and he told me that when I was ordering which is perfectly fine, but I'm not a fan of sweet pizza sauce but I gave it a shot anyways and hey they've been there for over 30 years so they must be doing something right... Check them out and see if you like it ”

“ Overall i believe this establishment is a 5 As a heads up, the sauce is on the sweet side. Different from most mainstream pizza places like LC or Jets. The liquor store next door sells by the slice so I'd reccomend you try one from there if you're unsure about the sauce. The customer service is excellent. One man in particular (you'd know the one) that works here is super nice, which is a pleasant change- up compared to most other pizza places you'd enter. Atmosphere is to be expected from a place that doesnt offer sit- down ”

“ First time here pizza was great and the cheese bread was cheesy will return when in town ”

“ It's pizza. Like it is supposed to be. Simple and good. The sauce is sweet and the bread is doughy. They are very nice! $11 for bread sticks and a large pizza ”

“ A small place, but every friday, my son and I have vegetarian pizza. This one was a winner. Lots of flavor. ”

“ This was my first pizza from Anthony's. XXL large (The New Yorker). Bacon, Onion and Pepperoni. It was a really good pizza. Good cheese, lots of toppings and awesome sauce. The person who took my order was incredibly friendly. I will definitly be ordering from here again. ”

“ Order from here multiple times a week! Our favorite pizza place and George and Ron make you feel like family; I don’t even give my name when I order anymore lol. I tell everyone to try this place! ”